The San Francisco 49ers just made one of the most talked-about decisions of Week 9 — and it might define the rest of their season.
Despite Brock Purdy’s heroic reputation and his $265 million extension, the Niners will roll with Mac Jones as their starting quarterback against the New York Giants this Sunday at MetLife Stadium.
Head coach Kyle Shanahan confirmed the decision after days of speculation, saying the team would take “a cautious approach” with Purdy’s toe injury that has sidelined him for over a month.
“Mac is going to be starting,” Shanahan told reporters. “Brock’s improving, but we won’t risk another setback. We’re easing him back smarter this time.”
It’s a move that might frustrate fans hoping for Purdy’s return — but also one that underlines San Francisco’s patience and trust in their system. With Jones delivering solid performances, the Niners have managed to stay in the playoff hunt with a 5-3 record, tied closely with the Seahawks and Rams in the NFC West.
Jones, who has thrown for 1,597 yards, 8 touchdowns, and 5 interceptions across six starts, isn’t flashy — but he’s been steady. His command of Shanahan’s offense has helped the 49ers stay afloat amid an injury storm that has ravaged both sides of the ball.
For Purdy, it’s a frustrating reality. Once seen as the franchise’s iron man, his 2025 campaign has been defined by pain and patience. The team’s medical staff continues to monitor his recovery, prioritizing long-term health over short-term desperation.
San Francisco fans are torn between loyalty to their golden boy and admiration for Jones’ quiet resilience. As one Bay Area columnist put it, “This is the rare moment when the 49ers’ backup might be their best hope to keep the dream alive.”
The Week 9 showdown with the Giants isn’t just another game — it’s a defining chapter for a team that’s learning to adapt, survive, and believe without its star.
And as the lights shine bright in New Jersey, the 49ers’ message is clear: the journey to greatness is never about one man — it’s about the team that refuses to break.
