Kansas City’s once-unshakable confidence in its special teams has begun to show cracks. Missed opportunities and shifting momentum are starting to raise serious questions about the stability of one key position.

The Chiefs’ offense remains electric, their defense resilient, but games are often decided by precision — not power. And lately, that precision hasn’t always been there when it matters most.

Veteran kicker Harrison Butker, long considered one of the NFL’s most reliable legs, finds himself under growing scrutiny. His recent inconsistency has sparked debate about whether Kansas City can still rely on his clutch performances.

“I know what I’m capable of,” Butker said after a tough outing last week. “One miss doesn’t define me — I’ll be ready when the next big moment comes.”

Head coach Andy Reid continues to publicly back his kicker, emphasizing experience and composure. Yet even Reid knows that the margin for error in playoff-caliber games is razor thin.

Butker’s track record includes game-winners and Super Bowl heroics, but every slump tests fan patience and front-office faith. Consistency, once his hallmark, now feels more like a question mark.

How much longer can the Chiefs trust Harrison Butker at kicker? pic.twitter.com/HIksrOluEc

— Adam Schetfar (@schetfar22173) October 11, 2025

Analysts point to technique, confidence, and the pressure of expectation as factors in his recent struggles. Still, the Chiefs know how quickly narratives can shift with just one decisive kick.

For now, Kansas City’s trust remains — but perhaps not unconditionally. The coming weeks may determine if Harrison Butker remains their long-term answer or just a reminder of how fleeting reliability can be.